Hypocrite's oath

Recently on a trip to Mumbai, I met a guy working with the largest consulting firm in the world (in terms of projected revenues as the consulting LLP firms never really publish their revenues). He was a pass out from a top B-school in the country and has been at his work for last 2 years. We spoke about various things and somehow the discussion came to the high fees charged by B-schools and how a high salary is imperative to pay off the loan. What I heard next was unbelievable, the consultant from the firm started boasting that he never ever paid even a penny of his educational loan back. He should be earning a minimum of 25 lacs every year and still is finding it impossible to pay off a loan worth 8 lacs. The hypocrisy from an highly educated Indian surprised and disappointed me at the same time.

I was more surprised to find out that consultant from the firm was not alone in his 'heroic' act. There are a lot of students, graduating out of top institutes of this country, creating more NPAs for the poor public sector banks which gave them loans at the time of need. To find out more, I spoke to the manager of a bank near a top educational institute. The bank was into giving educational loans to students earlier but stopped the practice as NPAs went through the roof. He told me that nearly 50% of the loans given to the students were NPAs and the only data they had of the students were mobile numbers which were disconnected and 'permanent addresses' which didn't exist. It sounded to me that the systems in PSB were so full of loop faults that students found it easy to cheat. The incentive to cheating grew when they found that people who cheated are getting along without any issues and the domino tumbled.

When one look closer into this phenomenon, one can see that the deluge of NPAs started in ayear when the top Indian B-schools increased their intake and economy ran into a bad patch. Students who came into these institutes with hopes of high salaries suddenly found themselves with an average job and a high EMI. They found it easier to default the EMI. The defaults may have started with an intention of delaying the payment. But when they saw there were no repercussions, they got bolder and got used to the defaults. Soon the people who landed up with good jobs found that their own batch mates were enjoying a privilege unavailable to them and wanted to join the bandwagon. So the domino effect started.

My reasoning may give you a hint that that I'm putting the blame on the banks and the system rather than the meritorious professionals who decide not to pay their dues. If the education they received at India's top schools have not given them even so much values, I think we are a failures as a nation. We have failed at creating individuals who cannot separate the right and wrong and lacking long term vision and we have failed at establishing institutions which could create such individuals.